What Is a Composition Roof? Understanding the Basics of This Popular Roofing Option

Walk through any suburban neighborhood in America, and look up. Chances are, you’re looking at the most popular roofing material in the country. It isn’t slate, and it certainly isn’t clay tile. It’s the reliable, ubiquitous composition shingle.

While you might hear contractors toss around terms like comp roof or asphalt shingles, homeowners often find themselves confused about what actually goes onto their house. You need a roof that protects your biggest investment, but you also want one that doesn’t drain your bank account or stick out like a sore thumb.

At Sweet Home Roofing, we believe an informed homeowner makes the best decisions. This guide strips away the jargon to explain exactly what a composition shingle roof is, why it dominates the market, and whether it’s the right choice for your next project.

What is a Composition Roof?

Before we dive into costs and lifespans, let’s answer the fundamental question: what is a composition roof?

The term composition refers to the fact that these shingles are a composite product made from several materials compressed together. They aren’t just one thing, like wood or metal. A standard composition shingle consists of three primary layers:

1. The Base Mat: This is the skeleton of the shingle. Historically, this was made of organic felt (paper or wood pulp), but modern shingles almost exclusively use a fiberglass mat. Fiberglass offers better fire resistance and strength without absorbing moisture.
2. The Asphalt Layer: The mat is coated in mineral-stabilized asphalt. This makes the shingle waterproof and heavy enough to stay put during a storm.
3. The Granules: The top layer consists of ceramic-coated mineral granules. These give the roof its color, but more importantly, they protect the asphalt from UV rays. Without these granules, the sun would bake and crack the asphalt in a matter of months.

This composite nature is what makes this composition roof material so versatile. Manufacturers can tweak the formula to create shingles that resist algae, reflect solar heat, or mimic the look of expensive cedar shakes.

The Three Main Types of Composition Shingles

Not all comp roof options are created equal. When you get a quote, you’ll typically see three tiers of quality. Understanding the difference can save you thousands in the long run.

1. 3-Tab Shingles (Strip Shingles)

These are the basic, entry-level option. They are flat, lightweight, and have a uniform look that resembles slate.

• Lifespan: 15–20 years.
• Wind Resistance: typically up to 60 mph.
• Best For: Rental properties or budget-conscious repairs.
• The Reality: While cheap upfront, they are slowly being phased out in favor of architectural shingles because they don’t last as long.

2. Architectural Shingles (Dimensional Shingles)

This is the new standard. If you see a composition shingle roof installed in the last ten years, it’s likely this type. They are thicker than 3-tabs and are laminated with an extra layer of asphalt to create a textured, 3D appearance.

• Lifespan: 25–30 years (with some warranties extending to 50 years).
• Wind Resistance: typically 110–130 mph.
• Best For: Most residential homes. They offer the best balance of cost and performance.

3. Luxury or Premium Shingles

These are heavyweights designed to replicate old-world roofing styles like slate or hand-split cedar shakes. They are significantly thicker and heavier than architectural shingles.

• Lifespan: 30–50+ years.
• Wind Resistance: Superior rating, often handling high-velocity hurricane zones.
• Best For: High-end homes or historic properties where aesthetics are paramount.

By The Numbers: Why Choose a Comp Roof?

We can talk about features all day, but let’s look at the data. Why do approximately 80% of U.S. homes sport asphalt composition shingles?

Affordability

Cost is the biggest driver. According to 2024 industry averages, a composition roof costs between $3.50 and $5.50 per square foot installed. Compare that to metal roofing ($9.00–$14.00) or slate ($15.00–$30.00), and the savings are massive. For a standard 2,000-square-foot roof, choosing composition over metal could keep $10,000 to $15,000 in your pocket.

Durability vs. Weight

A slate roof can weigh 800 to 1,500 pounds per “square” (a 10×10 foot area). Many home frames literally cannot support that weight without expensive structural reinforcement. In contrast, architectural composition shingles weigh roughly 200 to 250 pounds per square. They provide excellent protection without stressing your home’s structure.

Fire Rating

Safety matters. Most fiberglass-based composition shingles carry a Class A fire rating—the highest rating available. This means they are effective against severe exposure to fire and are not readily flammable. In areas prone to wildfires, this rating isn’t just a perk; it’s often a requirement for insurance.

Common Myths About Composition Roofs

Despite their popularity, misconceptions still float around. Let’s debunk a few.

Myth: Asphalt shingles are bad for the environment.
Reality: While they are petroleum-based, the industry has changed. According to the Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Association (ARMA), millions of tons of tear-off shingles are recycled annually, often repurposed into road paving materials.

Myth: They look cheap.
Reality: This might have been true in 1990. Today’s high-definition colors and shadow lines on architectural shingles create significant curb appeal. Unless you are standing right next to it, it can be hard to tell a luxury comp shingle from real slate.

Maintenance: Keeping Your Roof Healthy

One of the best features of composition roof material is that it is relatively low maintenance. However, “low maintenance” doesn’t mean “no maintenance.”

To get the full 25 or 30 years out of your roof, you need to pay attention to a few things:

1. Moss and Algae: In humid climates, you might see black streaks (algae) or green clumps (moss). While algae is mostly cosmetic, moss can lift shingles and let water underneath. Zinc or copper strips installed at the ridge can prevent this.
2. Ventilation is Key: This is the silent killer of roofs. If your attic gets too hot in the summer because of poor ventilation, it literally cooks the shingles from the bottom up. This causes premature blistering and cracking. Ensuring you have proper intake (soffit) and exhaust (ridge) vents is crucial.
3. Debris Removal: Don’t let leaves pile up in the valleys of your roof. Wet leaves trap moisture against the asphalt, which accelerates deterioration.

Is a Composition Roof Right for You?

At Sweet Home Roofing, we usually recommend a composition shingle roof if you fall into one of these categories:

• You want value. You plan to stay in the home for 10–20 years and want a reliable roof without overspending.
• You need variety. You have a specific color palette in mind for your home’s exterior. Comp roofs come in more colors than any other material.
• You want an easy installation. Most crews can install a comp roof in 1–3 days. Metal or tile roofs can take weeks.

However, if you are building a “forever home” that you want to pass down to your grandchildren, or if you live in an area with extreme hail hazards, you might explore metal or impact-resistant Class 4 shingles.

The Sweet Home Roofing Verdict

The composition shingle has earned its spot as the king of American roofing. It has evolved from a simple paper-based product into a high-tech, fiberglass-reinforced shield for your home. It offers the specific blend of durability, aesthetic flexibility, and price that modern homeowners demand.

Whether you are looking to replace an aging roof or building new, a comp roof is rarely a wrong choice. It’s the safe, smart, and stylish bet for protecting your family.

If you’re unsure which style matches your home, or you want to see samples of the latest architectural designs, reach out to us at (256) 445-9595 . We’re here to help you keep a solid roof over your head.

---

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

How long does a composition roof really last?

While warranties often say Lifetime or 50 Years, the realistic life expectancy depends on your climate. In mild climates, an architectural composition roof can last 25–30 years. In areas with harsh sun or extreme temperature swings, 20–25 years is more common. 3-tab shingles usually last 15–20 years.

Can I install new composition shingles over my old ones?

Technically, yes, this is called a “layover.” Most building codes allow for two layers of roofing. However, professional roofers rarely recommend it. Laying new shingles over old ones can trap heat (shortening the lifespan of the new roof), hide underlying deck rot, and void the manufacturer’s warranty. It’s usually better to tear off the old roof to inspect the decking.

What is the difference between asphalt and composition shingles?

There is no difference! The terms are used interchangeably. “Asphalt shingle” refers to the primary waterproofing ingredient, while “composition shingle” refers to the composite nature of the product (fiberglass mat + asphalt + granules).

Are composition shingles energy efficient?

Standard dark shingles absorb heat, which can warm up your attic. However, manufacturers now produce cool roof shingles. These use highly reflective granules that bounce solar energy away from the home, potentially lowering your cooling bills. Look for shingles that are ENERGY STAR® rated if energy efficiency is a priority.

How do I know if my composition roof needs replacing?

You don’t always need a ladder to tell. Look for granules in your gutters (a sign the asphalt is drying out), curling or buckling shingles, or missing tabs. Inside your home, look for dark spots on ceilings or light peaking through the attic boards. If your roof is over 20 years old, it’s time for a professional inspection.